Researching and reporting climate change

 
FacebookTwitterYouTubeFlickrGoogle+
Climate StateClimate State
Climate State
Researching and reporting climate change
  • Action
    • Carbon Tax
    • Clean Tech
    • Electric Car
    • Emissions Reduction
    • Solutions
  • Impacts
    • Deglaciation
    • Extreme Weather
    • Sea Ice
    • Sea Level Rise
    • Temperature
  • Science
    • Atmosphere
      • Chemistry
      • Greenhouse Effect
      • CO2 Carbon Dioxide
      • CH4 Methane
      • Methane Hydrate
      • N Nitrogen
      • Jet Stream
      • Polar Vortex
    • Biosphere
    • Cryosphere
      • Antarctica
      • Arctic
      • Permafrost
    • Feedbacks
    • Geosphere
    • Glaciology
    • Paleoclimatology
    • Polar Amplification
    • The Ocean
  • Wiki
    • Study
    • Visuals
    • Images of Deglaciation
  • Documentaries
  • ClimateState
    • Store
    • Support
    • Interviews
    • Issue 1
 0
  • No products in the cart.

Subtotal: €0,00

View Cart Checkout

  • Action
    • Carbon Tax
    • Clean Tech
    • Electric Car
    • Emissions Reduction
    • Solutions
  • Impacts
    • Deglaciation
    • Extreme Weather
    • Sea Ice
    • Sea Level Rise
    • Temperature
  • Science
    • Atmosphere
      • Chemistry
      • Greenhouse Effect
      • CO2 Carbon Dioxide
      • CH4 Methane
      • Methane Hydrate
      • N Nitrogen
      • Jet Stream
      • Polar Vortex
    • Biosphere
    • Cryosphere
      • Antarctica
      • Arctic
      • Permafrost
    • Feedbacks
    • Geosphere
    • Glaciology
    • Paleoclimatology
    • Polar Amplification
    • The Ocean
  • Wiki
    • Study
    • Visuals
    • Images of Deglaciation
  • Documentaries
  • ClimateState
    • Store
    • Support
    • Interviews
    • Issue 1

Why So Many Conservatives Deny The Climate Problem: They Hate The Solution

August 14, 20132013, Action, Climate Science, Denial, Energy, Media, Policy


On Friday (8 pm ET), MSNBC is airing Chris Hayes’s climate documentary, “The Politics of Power.”

On Thursday (1 pm ET), Chris Hayes is hosting a Google+ Hangout on the politics of climate change — with me, Andy Revkin, Kate Sheppard and a couple of others. You can watch it here.

 

Joe Romm notes:

Kudos to MSNBC for running this. Hayes is still the only major TV journalist who routinely devotes a significant amount of air time to telling the truth about global warming.

Speaking of which, on Monday’s All In show, Hayes had a good segment on “The Republican allure of climate change denialism.”

He makes the point that I have argued for the past decade, “the real reason conservatives don’t believe in climate science” is they can’t stand the solution.

Hayes plays an excerpt from remarks by hard-core denier Rep. Dana “dinosaur flatulence” Rohrabacher (R-CA):

ROHRABACHER: Just so you’ll know, global warming is a total fraud. The federal government, they want to create global government to control all of our lives. That’s what their game plan is. It’s step by step by step more and bigger control over our lives by higher levels of government. And global warming is simply that strategy in spades.

HAYES: Now, the whole “global warming is a liberal conspiracy” line is understandably a big hit among the conservative base, but in delivering that line, Congressman Rohrabacher tips his hand to the reasoning behind his global warming denialism, which basically goes like this: If global warming is real, then the government would need to intervene to fix it, but we don’t like government intervention. Therefore, global warming cannot be real.

That’s it. That is the logic behind the pervasive view on climate change on the right: We don’t like the solutions to this problem, so we officially declare this not to be a problem.

This is how the world ends, not with a bang, but a whimper.

Hayes then talks with Samuel Thernstrom, who served on George W. Bush’s Council on Environmental Quality. It is pretty painful to watch Thernstrom push the old Frank Luntz playbook — “Technology, technology, blah, blah, blah” — which Bush himself turned into a mantra.

For you Millennials out there, Luntz’s infamous (and still must-read) 2002 “Straight Talk” memo on climate change messaging was designed for conservatives who want to sound like they care about global warming even as they twist the knife in deeper:

Technology and innovation are the key in arguments on both sides. Global warming alarmists use American superiority in technology and innovation quite effectively in responding to accusations that international agreements such as the Kyoto accord could cost the United States billions. Rather than condemning corporate America the way most environmentalists have done in the past, they attack us for lacking faith in our collective ability to meet any economic challenges presented by environmental changes we make. This should be our argument. We need to emphasize how voluntary innovation and experimentation are preferable to bureaucratic or international intervention and regulation.

More than a decade later, the playbook is exactly the same! Basically, as Hayes shows, we progressives can talk about global warming as much as we want as long as we don’t propose anything that might actually solve the problem in a timely fashion. In this view, any climate proposal other than long-long-long-term research and development is automatically just a big government power grab. Of course, conservatives oppose increasing the budget for clean energy R&D, too, but who are we to get hung up on a foolish consistency? It’s not like the health and well-being of billions of people are at stake.

 

Read more, including the video segment with Rohrabacher 

wp theme by jazzsurf.com

11
SHARES
FacebookTwitter
AGWChris HayesClimate ProgressGOPJoe RommRohrabacher
Share this post
FacebookTwitterGoogle+LinkedIn
About the author

Editor

Related posts
Dry Conditions, then Tumbleweed Invaded Town
April 19, 2018
Meanwhile in Berlin, EU VP outlines Energiewende Industrial Revolution
April 19, 2018
Huge Climate Surprises for Canada, UK, France, Spain, and Many Others
April 16, 2018
In Just 10-15 Years World May Hit 2 Degrees of Warming
April 13, 2018
Is the Gulf Stream Really Slowing because of CO2?
April 12, 2018
ICE ALIVE – Documenting Life and Rapid Change
April 10, 2018

Leave a Reply

Be the First to Comment!

Leave Comment
avatar
wpdiscuz_captcharefresh
avatar
wpdiscuz_captcharefresh
  Subscribe  
Notify of
Popular Posts
  • David de Rothschild Discusses Cost of Fixing Climate Change
  • Dry Conditions, then Tumbleweed Invaded Town
  • The Brown Ocean Effect
  • Polar Vortex, Jet Stream and Climate Change
Climate State T-Shirt

Shop Europe | U.S.
Want to see more climate reporting and information like this?

ClimateState is independent and powered by community donations from people like you.

Visit our supporter page


Bitcoin wallet. The original & most secure hardware wallet.
Buy Bitcoins with Credit Card Binance is one of the largest Bitcoin exchanges in the world.
Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.



Climate State appreciates your support to make our coverage better.
● Donate Bitcoin 3F7RYgYRD2BmE2UcxgZqY5pccPcnsSBBbL
Buy Bitcoins with Credit Card
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Store
  • Climate State Supporter
  • Login
Footer